Drop · Methodology

Corrections log.

When Drop changes what it says about an ingredient, because it read a source wrongly, found new research or changed how it checks, the change is listed here with its date and its source. Newest first.

  1. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop showed its isotretinoin pregnancy advice to people who are breastfeeding, not the label’s own advice for them.
    What it covers
    Isotretinoin while breastfeeding
  2. New research

    What changed
    Drop now follows NIH’s LactMed, which rates trifarotene low risk while breastfeeding.
    What it covers
    Trifarotene while breastfeeding
  3. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop cited a pregnancy source for its advice to avoid hydroquinone while breastfeeding, and the advice stands.
    What it covers
    Hydroquinone while breastfeeding
  4. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop cited studies of cleansers and preservatives for its caution on essential oils, not studies of the oils.
    What it covers
    Roman Chamomile Oil for skin sensitive to fragrance; Clary Sage Oil for skin sensitive to fragrance; Ginger Root Oil for skin sensitive to fragrance; Grapefruit Oil for skin sensitive to fragrance; Lime Oil for skin sensitive to fragrance; Mandarin Orange Oil for skin sensitive to fragrance; Rosemary Leaf Oil for skin sensitive to fragrance; Rosewood Oil for skin sensitive to fragrance; Tangerine Oil for skin sensitive to fragrance; Tea Tree Oil for skin sensitive to fragrance; Vetiver Oil for skin sensitive to fragrance
  5. Changed how Drop checks

    What changed
    Drop now says no one has studied kojic acid, arbutin or alpha arbutin in pregnant or breastfeeding people: ask your OB.
    What it covers
    Alpha Arbutin while pregnant or breastfeeding; Arbutin while pregnant or breastfeeding; Kojic Acid while pregnant or breastfeeding
  6. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop read LHA (capryloyl salicylic acid) as salicylic acid and gave it that acid’s pregnancy advice.
    What it covers
    Salicylic Acid while pregnant or breastfeeding; Capryloyl Salicylic Acid while pregnant or breastfeeding
  7. Changed how Drop checks

    What changed
    Drop now says no one has studied bakuchiol in pregnancy or breastfeeding, and to ask your OB.
    What it covers
    Bakuchiol while pregnant, breastfeeding or trying to conceive
  8. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop didn’t say to take care with essential oils like tea tree for fragrance sensitivity.
    What it covers
    Roman Chamomile Oil for skin sensitive to fragrance; Clary Sage Oil for skin sensitive to fragrance; Ginger Root Oil for skin sensitive to fragrance; Grapefruit Oil for skin sensitive to fragrance; Mandarin Orange Oil for skin sensitive to fragrance; Rosemary Leaf Oil for skin sensitive to fragrance; Rosewood Oil for skin sensitive to fragrance; Tangerine Oil for skin sensitive to fragrance; Tea Tree Oil for skin sensitive to fragrance; Vetiver Oil for skin sensitive to fragrance
  9. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop didn’t say to take care with some fragrance allergens named in EU law, like balsam of Peru.
  10. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop answered fragrance sensitivity with sun advice for bergamot, lemon and bitter orange oils.
    What it covers
    Bergamot Oil for skin sensitive to fragrance; Lemon Oil for skin sensitive to fragrance; Bitter Orange Oil for skin sensitive to fragrance
  11. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop answered fragrance sensitivity with sun advice for lime oil.
    What it covers
    Lime Oil for skin sensitive to fragrance
  12. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop held back parsley and fig leaf extracts for fragrance sensitivity without a source.
  13. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop left tazarotene and trifarotene out when it advised under-18s against retinoids for aging.
    What it covers
    Tazarotene for people under 18; Trifarotene for people under 18
  14. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop left trifarotene out when it said to set retinoids aside during perioral dermatitis.
    What it covers
    Trifarotene with perioral dermatitis (a rash around the mouth)
  15. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop held back only ascorbic acid, not other vitamin C forms, during an eczema flare.
    What it covers
    3-O-Ethyl Ascorbic Acid during an eczema flare; Ascorbyl Glucoside during an eczema flare; Sodium Ascorbyl Phosphate during an eczema flare; Magnesium Ascorbyl Phosphate during an eczema flare; Ascorbyl Tetraisopalmitate during an eczema flare
  16. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop set aside only ascorbic acid, not other vitamin C forms, during perioral dermatitis.
    What it covers
    3-O-Ethyl Ascorbic Acid with perioral dermatitis (a rash around the mouth); Ascorbyl Glucoside with perioral dermatitis (a rash around the mouth); Sodium Ascorbyl Phosphate with perioral dermatitis (a rash around the mouth); Magnesium Ascorbyl Phosphate with perioral dermatitis (a rash around the mouth); Ascorbyl Tetraisopalmitate with perioral dermatitis (a rash around the mouth)
  17. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop left benzoyl peroxide out when it said to pause actives on a damaged skin barrier.
    What it covers
    Benzoyl Peroxide with a compromised barrier (raw, stinging skin)
  18. New research

    What changed
    Drop now says to skip benzoyl peroxide with rosacea, as dermatologists advise.
    What it covers
    Benzoyl Peroxide with active rosacea
  19. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop missed more fragrance allergens EU law makes labels name since 2023, such as menthol, peppermint oil and vanillin.
    What it covers
    Menthol for skin sensitive to fragrance; Peppermint Oil for skin sensitive to fragrance; Spearmint Oil for skin sensitive to fragrance; Eucalyptus Oil for skin sensitive to fragrance; Geranium Oil for skin sensitive to fragrance; Sweet Orange Oil for skin sensitive to fragrance; Linalyl Acetate for skin sensitive to fragrance; Vanillin for skin sensitive to fragrance; Pinene for skin sensitive to fragrance; Benzaldehyde for skin sensitive to fragrance
  20. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop missed tea tree leaf extract and water on labels, so they lacked tea tree oil’s pregnancy and under-18 warnings.
    What it covers
    Tea Tree Leaf Extract while pregnant, breastfeeding or trying to conceive; Tea Tree Leaf Extract for people under 18; Tea Tree Leaf Water while pregnant, breastfeeding or trying to conceive; Tea Tree Leaf Water for people under 18
  21. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop missed patchouli oil, a fragrance allergen that EU law has made labels name since 2023.
    What it covers
    Patchouli Oil for skin sensitive to fragrance
  22. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop listed the EU’s reproduction classification for butylphenyl methylpropional but gave no pregnancy caution.
    What it covers
    Butylphenyl Methylpropional while pregnant or trying to conceive
  23. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop based its clary sage pregnancy caution on a review that doesn’t name clary sage.
    What it covers
    Clary Sage Oil while pregnant
  24. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop read tocopheryl acetate as tocopherol, the plain form of vitamin E.
  25. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop read acetyl hexapeptide-8, palmitoyl tripeptide-1 and palmitoyl tetrapeptide-7 as other peptides.
  26. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop missed that its pregnancy source on essential oils names methyl salicylate.
    What it covers
    Methyl Salicylate while pregnant or breastfeeding
  27. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop didn’t read “Citrus Bergamia Peel Oil Expressed” as bergamot oil.
    What it covers
    Bergamot Oil for skin sensitive to fragrance
  28. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop missed fragrance allergens EU law makes labels name since 2023, such as lavender, rose and ylang-ylang oils.
    What it covers
    Lavender Oil for skin sensitive to fragrance; Ylang-Ylang Oil for skin sensitive to fragrance; Carvone for skin sensitive to fragrance; Methyl Salicylate for skin sensitive to fragrance
  29. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop missed that retinyl linoleate is a form of vitamin A, like retinyl palmitate.
    What it covers
    Retinyl linoleate while pregnant, breastfeeding or trying to conceive; Retinyl linoleate for people under 18; Retinyl linoleate during an eczema flare; Retinyl linoleate with active rosacea; Retinyl linoleate with a compromised barrier (raw, stinging skin); Retinyl linoleate with perioral dermatitis (a rash around the mouth)
  30. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop read BHA on an ingredient list, where it means an antioxidant, as salicylic acid.
    What it covers
    Salicylic Acid while pregnant or breastfeeding; Salicylic Acid during an eczema flare; Salicylic Acid with a compromised barrier (raw, stinging skin); Salicylic Acid with perioral dermatitis (a rash around the mouth)
  31. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop missed that retinal and lactic acid are best used on alternate nights, as it said for glycolic acid.
  32. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop missed that retinal and hydroxypinacolone retinoate are best started on alternate nights from salicylic acid.
  33. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop missed that mandelic acid and retinal, adapalene or hydroxypinacolone retinoate are best used on alternate nights.
  34. Changed how Drop checks

    What changed
    Drop now suggests adding mandelic acid and glycolic or lactic acid one at a time, as no study tested them together.
  35. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop did not count oleyl adapalenate, an adapalene ester, as a retinoid, so it got no pregnancy warning.
    What it covers
    Oleyl adapalenate while pregnant, breastfeeding or trying to conceive; Oleyl adapalenate for people under 18; Oleyl adapalenate during an eczema flare; Oleyl adapalenate with active rosacea; Oleyl adapalenate with a compromised barrier (raw, stinging skin); Oleyl adapalenate with perioral dermatitis (a rash around the mouth)
  36. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop missed two products with the same retinoid, like two retinal products, used on the same nights.
  37. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop read cetyl tranexamate mesylate, a form of tranexamic acid, as an unrelated ingredient.
  38. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop applied the fig sun-reaction warning to fig fruit extract, but the reports involve fig leaves and sap.
    What it covers
    Fig Fruit Extract
  39. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop read tripeptide-1, a peptide with no copper, as a copper peptide.
    Source
    Peptides
  40. Changed how Drop checks

    What changed
    Drop now suggests adding mandelic acid and salicylic acid one at a time, as no study tested the two together.
    What it covers
    Mandelic Acid; Salicylic Acid
  41. Changed how Drop checks

    What changed
    Drop now suggests adding mandelic or lactic acid and betaine salicylate one at a time, as no study tested them together.
    What it covers
    Mandelic Acid; Lactic Acid; Betaine Salicylate
  42. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop read citric acid listed after a preservative capped at 1% as an active acid, not a pH buffer.
  43. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop counted citric acid that one product rinses off and another uses as a pH buffer as an active acid.
  44. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop missed that a prescription adapalene label asks for care when it’s used with salicylic acid.
    What it covers
    Adapalene; Salicylic Acid
  45. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop missed that tretinoin’s labels say a salicylic acid product used with it can add to the irritation.
    What it covers
    Tretinoin; Salicylic Acid
  46. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop did not count retinyl propionate or retinyl acetate as retinoids, so they got no pregnancy warning on their own.
    What it covers
    Retinyl propionate while pregnant, breastfeeding or trying to conceive; Retinyl propionate for people under 18; Retinyl propionate during an eczema flare; Retinyl propionate with a compromised barrier (raw, stinging skin); Retinyl propionate with perioral dermatitis (a rash around the mouth); Retinyl propionate with active rosacea; Retinyl acetate while pregnant, breastfeeding or trying to conceive; Retinyl acetate for people under 18; Retinyl acetate during an eczema flare; Retinyl acetate with a compromised barrier (raw, stinging skin); Retinyl acetate with perioral dermatitis (a rash around the mouth); Retinyl acetate with active rosacea
  47. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop did not read “13-cis-retinoic acid” or other spellings of retinoic acid as a retinoid.
    What it covers
    Isotretinoin
  48. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop checked retinol and tretinoin against active rosacea, but not the other retinoids.
    What it covers
    Retinyl palmitate with active rosacea; Retinaldehyde with active rosacea; Adapalene with active rosacea; Hydroxypinacolone Retinoate with active rosacea; Tazarotene with active rosacea; Trifarotene with active rosacea
  49. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop did not read “Retinoic Acid” on a label as tretinoin, its other name.
    What it covers
    Tretinoin
    Source
    Tretinoin
  50. New research

    What changed
    Drop now follows NIH’s LactMed on tretinoin and adapalene while breastfeeding.
    What it covers
    Tretinoin while breastfeeding; Adapalene while breastfeeding; Tretinoin while pregnant or trying to conceive; Adapalene while pregnant or trying to conceive
  51. Changed how Drop checks

    What changed
    Drop now checks for two retinoid products used on the same nights.
  52. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop read citric acid late on an exfoliant’s list as an active acid, not a pH buffer.
  53. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop called hydroxypinacolone retinoate gentler than retinol, which its sources don’t say.
  54. Correction

    What was wrong
    Drop ranked retinal above retinol, but its source groups the two together.

How Drop reads the evidence, and what it does when it is wrong: Methodology.

Think Drop has something wrong? Tell us at hello@drop-skincare.com.